- Characters listed in bold denotes that the character dies during the episode
- Characters listed in italics denotes that the character is arrested during the episode or a gang is disbanded during the episode
- Characters listed in underline denotes that the character escaped arrest and still alive at the end of the episode or the gang is still active at the end of the episode
- Characters listed in italics and underline denotes the character's fate is unknown at the end of the episode.
- Characters listed in bold and underline denotes that character killed someone by accident
- Characters listed in italics and bold denotes that the character was pardoned for the crime
Contents |
Season 1
- Blink - Bogdan Ivanoff
- Creatures of the Night - Central Park Gardener
- American Dreamers - Aaron
- Grand Master
- Case 1 - The presenter guy
- Case 2 - Sushi bar woman
- A Man a Mile
- Case 1 - Joe Briggs
- Case 2 - Tina
- Outside Man - Victim's boyfriend
- Rain - Marvin Hummel
- Three Generations are Enough - Luke Sutton
- Officer Blue
- Case 1 - Jerald Brown
- Case 2 - Nick Vinchenzo
- Night, Mother
- Case 1 - Jason
- Case 2 - Eduardo
- Tri-Borough
- Case 1 - Will Galanis
- Case 2 - Ron Latham
- Case 3 - A frozen piece of feces from a Jet
- Recycling
- Case 1 - Millie Handford
- Case 2 - Newsstand Owner
- Tanglewood
- Case 1 - Tanglewood Boys
- Paul Montenassi (killed by Sonny Sassone)
- Sonny Sassone
- Case 2 - Tavia Greenberg
- Case 1 - Tanglewood Boys
- Blood, Sweat & Tears
- Case 1 - Lucas Nieman (committed suicide)
- Case 2 - Eric Slovenski
- 'Til Death Do We Part
- Case 1 - John Smith
- Case 2 - Lance Moretti
- Hush
- Case 1 - Kevin Hannigan
- Case 2 - Ron Bogda
- The Fall
- Case 1 - Tomas Perez
- Case 2 - Melvin Heckman's death was an accident
- The Dove Commission
- Case 1 - Bill Markoni
- Case 2 - Subway driver
- Crime & Misdemeanor
- Supply and Demand
- Case 1 - Joel Banks
- Case 2 - Jordan Benson
- On the Job
- Case 1 - Indian girl
- Case 2 - Jerome (shot by Officer Minhas)
- Case 3 - Officer Minhas
- The Closer
- What You See Is What You See
Season 2
- Summer in the City
- Case 1 - Victim's ex-wife and victim's assistnant
- Case 2 - The Bodyguard
- Case 3 - D.J. Pratt
- Grand Murder at Central Station
- Case 1 - Stanley Thatcher
- Case 2 - Paul Deacon
- Zoo York
- Case 1 - Felix Parker
- Case 2 - Tanya Danville
- Corporate Warriors
- Case 1 - Greg Thompson (killed by Jarrod Stanton)
- Case 2 - Jarrod Stanton
- Case 3 - Luke Robertson
- Dancing with the Fishes
- Case 1 - Vincent Williams
- Case 2 - Richard Daly
- Youngblood
- Manhattan Manhunt - Henry Darius
- Bad Beat
- City of the Dolls
- Jamalot
- Trapped
- Wasted
- Risk
- Stuck On You
- Fare Game
- Cool Hunter
- Case 1 - Stacie Avida (staged her suicide to frame Dr. Zimmer)
- Case 2 - Rico Cerda
- Necrophilia Americana
- Live or Let Die
- Super Men
- Case 1 - Vern Dox
- Case 2 - Maurice Bradford
- Run Silent, Run Deep - Tanglewood Boys
- All Access
- Case 1 - Felicia Badman
- Case 2 - Stella Bonasera (self-defense)
- Stealing Home
- Case 1 - James Vackner
- Case 2 - Elle Jeffries
- Heroes
- Case 1 - Stacey Gale
- Case 2 - D.J. Pratt
- Charge of this Post - Dean Lessing
Season 3
- People With Money
- Case 1 - Denney Lancaster
- Case 2 - Margo Demi
- Not What It Looks Like
- Case 1 - Holly Golightly
- Case 2 - Matthew Rayburn
- Love Run Cold
- Case 1 - Tonya's Boyfriend
- Case 2 - Sharon Cates
- Hung Out to Dry - Shane Casey
- Oedipus Hex
- Case 1 - Lily Becker
- Case 2 - Albert Linehart
- Open and Shut
- Case 1 - Tess Larson
- Case 2 - Grace Thomason
- Murder Sings The Blues
- Consequences
- And Here's To You, Mrs. Azrael
- Sweet Sixteen - Jesse's stepfather
- Raising Shane
- Case 1 - Peep Show Guy (murdered by Shane Casey)
- Case 2 - Shane Casey
- Silent Night
- Case 1 - Tom Howard
- Case 2 - Cole Rowen
- Obsession
- Case 1 - Terry
- Case 2 - Homeless Guy
- The Lying Game
- Some Buried Bones
- Case 1 - Chris Campbell
- Case 2 - Eddie Williams
- Heart of Glass
- Case 1 - Russell Ballard
- Case 2 - Kennedy Gable
- The Ride-In
- Sleight Out of Hand - Luke Blade
- A Daze Of Wine And Roaches
- Case 1 - Luther Vandeross
- Case 2
- What Schemes May Come
- Case 1
- Case 2
- Past Imperfect - Clay Dobson (committed suicide)
- Cold Reveal
- Case 1 - Toby Finch committed suicide
- Case 2 - Mindy Sanchez
- ...Comes Around
- Case 1 - John McEnroe (doppleganger)
- Snow Day - Wilder Irish Crime Family
Season 4
- Can You Hear Me Now?
- Case 1 - The 333 Stalker
- Case 2 - Morton Brite
- The Deep
- You Only Die Once
- Case 1 - Leo Tyler
- Case 2 - Kelsey Coulter
- Case 3 - The 333 Stalker
- Down the Rabbit Hole - Suspect X
- Boo - Henry Willens
- Commuted Sentences
- Case 1 - Steve Kaplan
- Case 2 - Amber Stanton
- Buzzkill - Lea and Paul Campbell
- One Wedding and a Funeral - Caterer
- The Thing About Heroes - Andrew Bedford
- Child's Play
- Happily Never After
- Case 1 - Felix Hall
- Case 2 - Tyler
- All in the Family
- Playing with Matches
- Case 1 - Accident
- Case 2 - Don Szabo
- DOA For a Day - Suspect X
- Right Next Door - Bonnie Dillard
- Like Water for Murder - The Cabbie Killer
- Admissions
- Case 1 - The Cabbie Killer
- Case 2 - Hank Bedford (murdered by Stan Gerrard)
- Personal Foul
- Case 1 - Paula
- Case 2 - The Cabbie Killer
- Taxi - The Cabbie Killer
- Hostage - Bank Robbery Crew
- Derrick James
- Ethan Scott
Season 5
- Veritas - Bank Robbery Crew
- Derrick James (murdered by Ethan Scott)
- Ethan Scott
- Page Turner - Joel Paulson
- Turbulence - Susan
- Sex, Lies, And Silicone - Trevor Jones
- The Cost of Living
- Case 1 - James Sutton
- Case 2 - Greek Antique Smugglers
- Enough - Jacob Donovan
- Dead Inside - Annie McBride
- My Name is Mac Taylor
- Case 1 - David Oka
- Case 2 - MacQuinn Taylor
- The Box - Steve Barker
- The Triangle - Jamie Sunderland
- Forbidden Fruit
- Case 1 - Marina Morton
- Case 2 - Greek Antique Smugglers
- Help - Colin Clark
- Rush to Judgement
- Case 1 - Todd Fleming drugged himself
- Case 2 - Alex The Court Security Guard
- She's Not There
- The Party's Over - Jake Kaplan
- No Good Deed - Enrico Palermo
- Green Piece - Teddy Meyhem
- Point of No Return
- First Half of Case 1 - Steve Alvarez
- Second Half of Case 1 - Marty Pino
- Case 2 - Greek Antique Smugglers
- Communication Breakdown
- Prey
- The Past, Present and Murder
- Yahrzeit
- Greater Good - Korita
- Grounds For Deception - Greek Antique Smugglers
- George Kolovos (killed by Tasso)
- Kostas Papakota (killed by Tasso)
- Tasso Papakota (shot by Mac)
- Pay Up - A Group of Kidnappers
- Carl Miller
- Vic Denton
- Blaine Spezak
- Simon Cade (shot by Don Flack)
Season 6
- Epilogue - New York Extortionists
- David Wilson
- Tyson Melo (killed by Jake Calaveras)
- Jake Calaveras
- Lat/Long - Hollis Eckhart
- Cuckoo's Nest - Hollis Eckhart
- Manhattanhenge - Hollis Eckhart
- Redemptio - Shane Casey
- Vacation Getaway - Shane Casey
Season 7
- The 34th Floor
- Case 1 - Shane Casey (shot by Lindsay Messer)
- Case 2
- Hammer Down - The Zetas
Season 8
- Cavallino Rampante - Dominik Janos
- Crushed - John Curtis
- Crossroads - John Curtis
- Means to an End - John Curtis (shot by Jo)
Season 9
- Reignited - Leonard Brooks
- Where There's Smoke... - Leonard Brooks
- Clue: SI - Steve Davis
- Command+P - Andy Lewis
- Civilized Lies - Anthony Lombardo and Eric Blaylock
- Nine Thirteen - Macy Sullivan