• Characters listed in bold denotes that the character dies during the episode
• Characters listed in italics denotes that the character is arrested during the episode or a gang is disbanded during the episode
• Characters listed in underline denotes that the character escaped arrest and still alive at the end of the episode or the gang is still active at the end of the episode
• Characters listed in italics and underline denotes the character's fate is unknown at the end of the episode.
• Characters listed in bold and underline denotes that character killed someone by accident
• Characters listed in italics and bold denotes that the character was pardoned for the crime

Season 1

• Tanglewood - Tanglewood Boys

Season 2

• Grand Murder at Central Station
  • Case 1
  • Case 2
• Zoo York
  • Case 1 - Felix Parker
  • Case 2 - Tanya Danville
• Manhattan Manhunt - Henry Darius
• Run Silent, Run Deep - Tanglewood Boys
• All Access
  • Case 1
  • Case 2 - Frankie Mala (killed by Stella in self-defense)
• Heroes
  • Case 1 - Stacey Gale
  • Case 2 - D.J. Pratt
• Charge of this Post - Dean Lessing

Season 3

• Hung Out to Dry - Shane Casey
• Raising Shane - Shane Casey
• Sleight Out of Hand
  • Case 1 - Luke Blade
  • Case 2
• Past Imperfect - Clay Dobson (committed suicide)
• ...Comes Around
  • Case 1 - John McEnroe (doppleganger)
• Snow Day - Colm Gunn

Season 4

• Down the Rabbit Hole - Suspect X
• The Thing About Heroes - Andrew Bedford
• DOA For a Day - Suspect X
• Like Water for Murder - The Cabbie Killer
• Admissions - The Cabbie Killer
• Personal Foul
  • Case 1
  • Case 2 - The Cabbie Killer
• Taxi - The Cabbie Killer
• Hostage - Bank Robbery Crew
  • Derrick James
  • Ethan Scott

Season 5

• Veritas - Bank Robbery Crew
  • Derrick James (murdered by Ethan Scott)
  • Ethan Scott
• My Name is Mac Taylor
  • Case 1 - David Oka
  • Case 2 - MacQuinn Taylor
• Help - Colin Clark
• Point of No Return
  • First Half of Case 1 - Steve Alvarez
  • Second Half of Case 1 - Marty Pino
  • Case 2 - Greek Antique Smugglers
• Greater Good - Korita
• Grounds For Deception - Kostas Papakota and Tasso Papakota (Kostas killed by Tasso; Tasso shot by Mac)
• Pay Up - A Group of Kidnappers
  • Carl Miller
  • Vic Denton
  • Blaine Spezak
  • Simon Cade (Cade shot by Don Flack)

Season 6

• Epilogue - New York Extortionists
  • David Wilson
  • Tyson Melo (killed by Jake Calaveras)
  • Jake Calaveras
• Lat/Long - Hollis Eckhart
• Cuckoo's Nest - Hollis Eckhart
• Manhattanhenge - Hollis Eckhart
• Redemptio - Shane Casey
• Vacation Getaway - Shane Casey

Season 7

• The 34th Floor
  • Case 1 - Shane Casey (shot by Lindsay Messer)
  • Case 2
• Hammer Down - The Zetas
  • Casey Steele

Season 8

• Cavallino Rampante - Dominik Janos
• Crushed - John Curtis
• Crossroads - John Curtis
• Means to an End - John Curtis (shot by Jo)

Season 9

• Reignited - Leonard Brooks
• Where There's Smoke... - Leonard Brooks
• Clue: SI - Steve Davis
• Command+P - Andy Lewis