- Jake Tarland
- Matthew Tarland
- Ellie Brass
The group targeted, prostitutes, strippers and other sex trade workers who sought shelter at the Fellowship for the Fallen Angels. They would kill them in various ways, though the first victims were killed by strangulation or some other form of asphyxiation. The victims were then posed to look like illustrations from a 16th century edition of Dante's The Divine Comedy. The group's calling card was leaving behind hollowed-out bibles with a rectangular case inside near the victims. Circles were also prominently featured at the crime scenes, not just in objects, but also carved on the cases.
- Teresa Hill (attempted; strangled; represented the first circle, "Limbo") killed in 19??
- Megan Ramirez (strangled and mummified; represented the second circle, "Lust")
- Chloe Rudolf (choked on a chocolate covered locust; represented the third circle, "Gluttony")
- Morgan Brody (abducted, held hostage and shot in the back by Ellie; survived)
- Denise (stabbed through the heart; represented the fifth circle, "Violence")
- Angela Banner (killed and tied to a pole; represented the sixth circle, "Heresy")
- Oliver Tate (killed by an explosion; represented the seventh circle, "Violence")
- Matthew Tarland (member; stabbed and shot to death by Ellie)
- Nancy Brass (shot by Ellie)